A bad reference
Wednesday, November 26th, 2008Hi, I’m Andrew and I’m not sure if this is your area of expertise but I’d be intrested to see what you think.
I recently was offerd a job with a company. I said yes and they said they would check my refrences. I gave them two and today human resorces phoned and asked for another refrence. This has got me worried that my old company has said something bad about me. The employer I had listed was from a company I left about two years ago and my manager had changed since then so im not sure weather its because no one remmembers me or if I got a bad reference. I didnt do anything wrong at the job. I am now starting to think maybe i shouldn’t take this job as I feel bad things may have been said and that they might think I’m no good. Do you think I should turn this down? I didnt ask them why they wanted another refrence. If I did ask, would they have told me? Many thanks Andrew
Hi Andrew.
Few employers will risk providing a negative reference for you no matter what your reason for leaving the company. Rather, they will either give you a stock “name, rank, and serial number” recommendation or, however reluctantly, a positive reference. However, often times you can tell as much by what a former employer isn’t saying. For example, if a former employer didn’t have a lot of positive things to say about you, that alone could make a company want to check additional references.
My guess is they have requested an additional reference because your former supervisor no longer works at your previous company and they wanted to talk with someone who could speak to your work ethic and ability to work well with others. Hopefully you were able to provide them with another reference.
Andrew, I wouldn’t put a whole lot of effort into worrying about why you were asked for a third reference, assuming you have nothing to hide. You don’t, do you? What I would do in the future is make sure your references are not only reachable but give them a heads-up as well that they might be called. That way they are not put on the spot and unprepared.
-Dr. Mac

